Showing posts with label Front Street Study. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Front Street Study. Show all posts

Monday, September 23, 2024

A Safety Plan too Aspirational and Questions on Front Street: At the MPO

The Policy Committee for our Metropolitan Planning Commission meets on Tuesday the 24th to adopt the new Metropolitan Transportation Safety Action Plan.

Ticketable: On Commercial between Hoyt and Rural

The MPO did not in the end incorporate more of an emphasis on system speed and legal, lawful posted speed, which are often too high and too lethal for an urban area. They focused more on speeding above the posted speed.

Previously:

The edits from the August draft to the September final version are mostly small.

Perhaps the most consequential set of edits undercuts the document as any kind of "action plan."

Merely a "guiding framework"

The plan doesn't actually commit the MPO or its members to doing anything. It is mainly aspirational, merely a "guiding framework" and list of "recommended strategies." It's more hope than plan.

Monday, July 1, 2024

North Front Street Study Likely to Reveal Interesting Archeology and History

As details about the funding on the north Front Street study come out, it is interesting to consider the archeological details which will complicate it. (In good ways mostly!)

Lots of photos taken from here

One of the biggest is a millrace that ran along Division and turned the corner north onto Front Street. It's under there somewhere!

Millrace on Front Street
(Salem Library Historic Photos)

You can see its course on the 1895 Sanborn map (click to enlarge), photographed from the mill at top and building in pink on the map below.  At the time the map was drawn the race was planked. The photo shows it exposed.

Friday, June 28, 2024

North Front Street Study wins $2.7 Million Grant

This morning online, but not yet in print, the paper has news that on Wednesday the Feds announced that Salem had won a $2.7 million RAISE grant to write a study and plan for Front Street north of Union Street.

Brief one-pager in announcement

There's really not much of substance in the announcement, and so the story (paywalled) is mostly context and a rehearsal of the background.

The one-page fact sheet mentions "nine at-grade rail crossings" missing "crossing gates or warning lights." But it does not mention anything about studying relocating the rails. This remains a confusing part of the study concept. The railroad runs right down the center of Front Street there! That's a real multi-modal challenge. How it deals with the railroad will be one of the most interesting, if not absolutely the most interesting, part of the project. (And what about running a WES extension down the line, which is the former Oregon Electric route, and about which there is more and more talk?)

Earlier this year the City had said "The total budget is expected to be between $2.5 and $5.0 million." The grant amount of $2.7 million is on the low end, and that could shape expectations for the final plan. 

See previous notes on the former Truitt Bros. Cannery and prospects for a future project, very much at the center of the Front Street analysis. It's hard to see the timeline on redeveloping the cannery site, since reshaping Front Street will be years away.

Thursday, February 22, 2024

City Names Developers for Former UGM/Saffron Site, Shares more on Front Street Study

At City Council for Monday is Big Block 50 news, the former UGM/Saffron site. As Urban Renewal Agency, the City has selected developers and looks to approve a Memorandum of Understanding to kick things off.

There are two of them, one based in Portland, the other with a trio of offices in Boise, Bend, and Eugene. 

Edlin & Co. is the successor firm to Gerding Edlin, which did a lot of the Pearl District in Portland, starting with the Brewery Blocks, the redevelopment of the old Weinhard Brewery and nearby area. This included a grocery store, Whole Foods, in an Art Deco-y building one block west of Powell's. They've done a lot of LEED certified buildings, and recent work includes an apartment block to Passive House standards. They've also done affordable housing projects. (And they've done lots of towers too, both in the Pearl and the South Waterfront, but it's the midrise examples that seem most relevant here.)

Brewhouse (l) and Whole Foods (r)
NW 12th & Couch, Portland

The Kiln, 19 apartments to Passive House standards

The other firm, deChase Miksis is working on redeveloping the former EWEB Steam Plant on the Eugene riverfront, and successfully redeveloped a mid-century furniture warehouse on Willamette Street, where Claim 52 has a pub now. 

Claim 52 on a summer evening

Both firms have shown a genuine interest in reuse of older buildings, and even though the City scraped the site and reuse is not in play here, this interest is a very good sign that they will develop sensitively and appropriately.

The choice for the two firms on the surface certainly looks appropriate, with a very good chance to be more than that — to be terrific. This is exciting stuff.

Friday, June 9, 2023

A New Study for Front Street, Lingering Questions on McGilchrist

On Monday, acting as the Urban Renewal Agency, Council will consider a proposal for a new study on Front Street just north of the Union Street Bridge.

Imagining Front Street at Market Street

You will recall the recent excitement over the prospect of redeveloping the cannery site on Front at Market Street. (Previous notes here.) 

The City proposes to budget $250,000 in unallocated Urban Renewal funding for two studies, $150,000 for a new one on Front Street and $100,000 to update the grocery store study from 2018:

The Front Street multi-modal project encompasses the corridor that will link the Downtown area to the Cannery property project north of the URA. The corridor is impacted by the rail line, a potential trail, a pedestrian bridge over Mill Creek, and bicycle accommodation, which all need to be accounted for during the planning phase and before the developer finalizes plans. The grocery store update is to refresh data from the 2018 analysis in the Riverfront-Downtown URA given increased development completed and underway.

With the railroad, and the desires for housing and for substantial retail and recreation amenities, reconfiguring Front Street will be a challenge - but a worthy one!

That study will probably have a public process and hopefully direct conversation about trade-offs and different notions of balancing all the user types.

It is possible to imagine a lively district there in 2050.

By contrast, it is much harder to imagine a lively district along McGilchrist in 2050. 

This is one of the things that hampers discussion of McGilchrist. Certainly in the nearish term, say 2030 or 2033, even with terrific bike lanes and sidewalks, there is not going to be a high volume of people walking or rolling there, even with the brewery district, the Social Security office, and Veterans clinic. Non-auto travel will remain occasional rather than constant. So from that standpoint it may not be the best place for the City to focus on state-of-the-art bike lanes and sidewalks.

Further out, it's harder to imagine conditions on McGilchrist in 2050. Will robot trucks be the main user? Technological change may impact that area more than downtowns, where the basic act of something like eating in a restaurant remains tethered to the forms of our embodied existence.

But even granting that truck and auto traffic will remain primary on McGilchrist, speed remains a concern.

Over on FB, Commissioner Slater posted 15 theses from the meeting, representing the City position. Most of them seem broadly true and accurate, thought it is possible to quibble with some of them on smaller matters of degree and detail. But the whole seems driven by a tone of "Look at how much bigger it could be. Be thankful for the concessions we have already made." The lack of a public conversation about what we want from McGilchrist shows here.

I want to look more closely at two of the theses and to contest them a little, maybe more for future conversations and studies, for the "next time," rather than for McGilchrist itself:

  • The current professional understanding is that it is safer for bikes to cross intersections on the street, which is how this street is designed.
  • The engineer who did the design believes that speeds will average 30-35 mph.

Here is an enlarged detail from the plan at 22nd Street. (Comments in red and pink added.)

Eastbound on McGilchrist at 22nd
(red and pink comments added)

One concern is the set of ramps and transitions between the multi-use path and the short segment of on-street, paint-only bike lane at intersections.