Monday, June 12, 2023

Thinking about Governance Structure and Cost Escalation: At the MPO

The technical committee for our Metropolitan Planning Organization meets on Tuesday the 13th, and there are a number of items to note in passing.

New website and home page

The Council of Governments, which hosts and staffs the MPO has a new website. It's optimized for mobile devices, and seems to load very slowly on a desktop. The first two things, finding the TAC meeting notice and the new location for the area bike map were easy enough, though. Maybe as we use it more there will be more to say.

On the meeting, as the MPO continues to grapple with cost escalation, centered on immediate needs for the Verda Lane project and then rippling out to other projects, a source of value engineering on the McGilchrist project may be in play. One of the proposals is to shave $4 million from the first phase, the intersection with 22nd. That may be of interest to critics of the McGilchrist project.

A way to shave funding for McGilchrist?

Other possible effects include pushing off the new sidewalk for Commercial Street SE between Vista and Ratcliff from 2026 out to 2028.

City Council, June 12th

Also at Council on Monday is a proposal for an employee payroll tax. Though the City slips in "unsheltered services," and some want to think that might mean funding for the Navigation Center or other services like that, the center of the list is Fire and Police, "community safety."

Probably it would be better to think of "unsheltered services" under "housing crisis" rather than "community safety." Some unsheltered people might commit crimes, but being unsheltered is not itself a crime or inherently a danger to the citizenry. This is a category mistake, welcomed and intended by some, but not something the City should embrace.

Additionally between recent reports on the frequency of Police shootings here, unnecessary and misdirected force used in policing protests, and the coverup going on with Marganne Allen's death, Council should be under no hurry to give Police additional resources until they figure it out.

Then there is the matter of Fire response, the proportion of calls that are medical rather than fire, and the best way to deliver services that corresponds to the actual call mix.

Others will have plenty to say and better things to say.

The airport is on the agenda for two items, creating a formal project to receive the last of the Fairivew Urban Renewal Area funds, and accepting a small amount of funding from Marion County. There does not seem to be anything useful to say on this folly any more.

Public Hearings on the two budgets, one for the City and one for the Urban Renewal Agency, are on the agenda. Hopefully others will drill into them and have comment.

Bullets:

Sunday, June 11, 2023

Is there a Heritage Tree on Union and Cottage? Checking in on the Union Street Bikeway

With the City announcement of construction starting on the Union Street Bikeway, and then an enthusiastic note over at Salem Bike Vision, it was time to check in on the venerable honeysuckle at Union and Cottage.

Honeysuckle at Union and Cottage

Honeysuckle in 2013

To this non-professional eye, it looked like construction was shaving the root zone awfully close. With signage and netting carelessly draped over it, it didn't exactly look like it was getting much special care.

Friday, June 9, 2023

A New Study for Front Street, Lingering Questions on McGilchrist

On Monday, acting as the Urban Renewal Agency, Council will consider a proposal for a new study on Front Street just north of the Union Street Bridge.

Imagining Front Street at Market Street

You will recall the recent excitement over the prospect of redeveloping the cannery site on Front at Market Street. (Previous notes here.) 

The City proposes to budget $250,000 in unallocated Urban Renewal funding for two studies, $150,000 for a new one on Front Street and $100,000 to update the grocery store study from 2018:

The Front Street multi-modal project encompasses the corridor that will link the Downtown area to the Cannery property project north of the URA. The corridor is impacted by the rail line, a potential trail, a pedestrian bridge over Mill Creek, and bicycle accommodation, which all need to be accounted for during the planning phase and before the developer finalizes plans. The grocery store update is to refresh data from the 2018 analysis in the Riverfront-Downtown URA given increased development completed and underway.

With the railroad, and the desires for housing and for substantial retail and recreation amenities, reconfiguring Front Street will be a challenge - but a worthy one!

That study will probably have a public process and hopefully direct conversation about trade-offs and different notions of balancing all the user types.

It is possible to imagine a lively district there in 2050.

By contrast, it is much harder to imagine a lively district along McGilchrist in 2050. 

This is one of the things that hampers discussion of McGilchrist. Certainly in the nearish term, say 2030 or 2033, even with terrific bike lanes and sidewalks, there is not going to be a high volume of people walking or rolling there, even with the brewery district, the Social Security office, and Veterans clinic. Non-auto travel will remain occasional rather than constant. So from that standpoint it may not be the best place for the City to focus on state-of-the-art bike lanes and sidewalks.

Further out, it's harder to imagine conditions on McGilchrist in 2050. Will robot trucks be the main user? Technological change may impact that area more than downtowns, where the basic act of something like eating in a restaurant remains tethered to the forms of our embodied existence.

But even granting that truck and auto traffic will remain primary on McGilchrist, speed remains a concern.

Over on FB, Commissioner Slater posted 15 theses from the meeting, representing the City position. Most of them seem broadly true and accurate, thought it is possible to quibble with some of them on smaller matters of degree and detail. But the whole seems driven by a tone of "Look at how much bigger it could be. Be thankful for the concessions we have already made." The lack of a public conversation about what we want from McGilchrist shows here.

I want to look more closely at two of the theses and to contest them a little, maybe more for future conversations and studies, for the "next time," rather than for McGilchrist itself:

  • The current professional understanding is that it is safer for bikes to cross intersections on the street, which is how this street is designed.
  • The engineer who did the design believes that speeds will average 30-35 mph.

Here is an enlarged detail from the plan at 22nd Street. (Comments in red and pink added.)

Eastbound on McGilchrist at 22nd
(red and pink comments added)

One concern is the set of ramps and transitions between the multi-use path and the short segment of on-street, paint-only bike lane at intersections.

Thursday, June 8, 2023

Decentering Samuel Thurston in Understanding the History of Oregon

The Oregon Historical Society announced the 2023 Joel Palmer Award for the best article published in the Quarterly over the previous year. This year a German historian from Leipzig, Julius Wilm, won for his article, "Old Myths, Turned on Their Heads: Settler Agency, Federal Authority, and the Colonization of Oregon."

Samuel Thurston
IOOF Pioneer Cemetery
Memorial Day weekend

It was particularly interesting for the critique of the way we have understood Samuel Thurston.

It took until September 1850 to pass the Donation Land Claim Act (DLCA) to legalize existing claims and offer land donations to incoming settlers. The delay deeply frustrated White Oregonians, and when the territory’s first non-voting congressional delegate Samuel R. Thurston departed for Washington, D.C., in the fall of 1849, lobbying for a land law was on the top of his agenda. Authors of later retellings — even those critical of the policy — have greatly exaggerated Thurston’s part in getting the law passed and his input in its framing, widely crediting him with authoring the law or being central to its passage. “Samuel Thurston wrote the Donation Land Act,” a web exhibition on the Oregon Constitution commissioned by the state archives states matter-of-factly. Authors of the classic pioneer-centered hagiography put Thurston on a pedestal as yet another settler-savior who through sheer willpower, as Whitman and Jason Lee had previously, forced reluctant politicians in the metropole to help the White frontier community that was on the verge of being forgotten. Authors of more-recent studies attribute to Thurston the most egregious features of the DLCA — its disregard of Native land rights and exclusion of Black settlers — thereby separating those features from their origin in imperial power politics.

This central importance that historians attribute to Thurston is based on an isolated reading of sources that are not understood in their context nor in their inherent contradictions....The exaggerated agency that authors of both hagiographic and critical history attributed to Thurston obfuscates the role of national political imperatives in developing the law.

2023 Joel Palmer Award winner

This looks like an interesting debate! Maybe Thurston was more of a cog in the wheel than we have supposed. If you are interested in the pre-Statehood, settlement period, and have not already read the article, it is available for free from the website (link at top). Check it out.

Monday, June 5, 2023

McGilchrist at the Planning Commission Tuesday

The Planning Commission meets tomorrow, Tuesday the 6th, and apart from the consent calendar, they have one item only on the agenda, an information presentation on the McGilchrist project.

the agenda item

I'm not sure there's very much new to say specifically about the project, though we'll review or repeat some points. 

More interesting might be how the project is currently situated at a number of different conversations and shows how the City is or is not addressing them or making progress on them.

Communications

Unfortunately there is no Staff Report, and the agenda item links only to the new "fact sheet" and to the project website. These are canned PR items, a bit of propaganda more than contributions to the debate, very much unilaterally conceived, being units of thought pushed out to the wider citizenry.

But on social media and elsewhere citizens have already raised a number of issues, and City Staff might have been more directly responsive to those comments and critique. Merely to repeat the "fact sheet" and project web page is largely to evade those questions and to assume a sympathetic audience at the Planning Commission. Hopefully in person Commissioners and the citizenry will have good questions. 

Like Councilor Stapleton has!

via FB
(The auto-generated caption is not the best)

There are more problems with communications. Back to the Commission agenda, the link in the agenda doesn't even work!

Busted link

The new City website does not seem to have a good architecture that is easy for Staff to use in updating and convenient for citizens to find information.

Thursday, June 1, 2023

Take ODOT Survey on Commercial/Liberty and Trade/Ferry State Highway Couplets

ODOT's got a weird survey out on the Liberty/Commercial and Trade/Ferry/Parkway couplets as part of State Highways 99E 

The street/highway segments

They say

We already have some planned projects on OR 99E and OR 22, and through this effort, we will identify specific bicycle and pedestrian improvements that may be added to them.

They show pictures of different crosswalks and bike lanes to illustrate possibilities, but they didn't choose particularly vivid ones. It's like they weren't trying very hard to illustrate concepts or to select images to get people excited about improvements for non-auto travel.

Then they start the survey. It's nearly all about crosswalks. The northmost section I rarely visit, and on that do not have opinions. (Frequent users/visitors of these streets will have important local knowledge, and hopefully they will comment most, as they will notice demand and need where less frequent visitors may not notice.)

The next section is right by Grocery Outlet, and a crosswalk at D Street has always seemed like it would be helpful. Interestingly, they do not show a circle on both Commercial and LIberty, but a crosswalk only on Commercial dead-ending in the median would be useless!

D Street needs a crosswalk!

Union Street is already getting crossing improvements, and because of the RR as a barrier, east-west walking travel along Center or Marion has not seemed high demand. Crossing at Chemeketa is, and it would be nice to see enhanced crossing facilities at Chemeketa, not just mid-block.