Showing posts with label Winter-Maple Bike Boulevard Study. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Winter-Maple Bike Boulevard Study. Show all posts

Monday, September 25, 2023

Senior Mobility Fair, Flood Plains, Missing Crosswalk Stop Sign, Critical Mass - Bits

Just some short bits for the week.

Tuesday: How to Ride a Bus: Mobility Fair for Seniors

Mobility Fair for Seniors

Thursday: Flood Plain Open House

In conversation about the overlay zones, a person suggested 12th street was better for mixed-use projects than Commercial Street. A trend in thinking about flooding is reducing development in flood plains, and there is one on and around 12th Street at Pringle Creek and Clark Creek. This is another reason we should encourage infill on higher elevation sites. Shunting infill to flood plains in order to insulate from change wealthier residents on the hills is not prudent.

Housing and density in flood plains? (excerpt)

The Open House on Thursday the 28th isn't necessarily going to touch on this directly, but as we think about trees and creeks, we have to start accepting more height and density where we do build in order to preserve trees and creeks. Building up means more trees and riparian zones.

Wednesday, May 3, 2023

Budget Committee on Bike Lanes and Photo Enforcement

The Budget Committee meets tonight, Wednesday the 3rd, and in the Addendum to the previous week's meeting on the CIP, are several notes on transportation.

Especially interesting was an explicit mention of what has not yet been done on the Winter-Maple Greenway.

To Do list on Winter-Maple Greenway

What's up with the Greenway

One item that continues to be odd is a disconnect at the intersection of the Union and Winter bikeways.

The "to do" list shows a roundabout still for Winter and Union. The most recent Union Street plans do not allude to any future roundabout. They also employ sidewalkification at the bus stop.

No roundabout; sidewalkification instead

It would be helpful to see evidence that the two plans are properly coordinated.

Monday, December 13, 2021

City to hold Second Teleconference on Union Street Greenway

Tomorrow, Tuesday the 14th, the City is hosting a teleconference on the latest concepts for the Union Street Greenway, which will connect the Union Street bridge to the Winter-Maple Greenway, and in later phases may connect to the 12th Street Promenade. The current plans end at Summer Street and use existing legacy bike lanes and routing via Chemeketa to points east.

Warning signs, but no striped crosswalks or signals
Planned for bulb-outs and traffic signal

They have published no new information about any revisions, and so there is nothing really to say yet. Hopefully they will publish concept drawings and not restrict everything to the video feed. Later there will be more to say. 

From the City:

The City of Salem will present an updated design for the Union Street Family Friendly Bikeway Project on December 14, 2021 at 7 p.m. The public meeting will take place as a Virtual Open House via Zoom, where design elements of the project will be presented to the public.

The proposed project, which seeks to add bike lanes to Union Street between Commercial Street NE and Summer Street NE, will enhance the overall pedestrian, bike riding, and vehicular safety of Union. The project will provide separated bike lanes, road striping, improved crosswalks, and parking as required. When all segment pieces are complete, this project will connect with the 134-mile Willamette Valley Scenic Bikeway. Additionally, the intersection of Union Street NE and Liberty Street NE will be improved to include a traffic signal and bulb out corners to improve safety for both bicycles and pedestrians.

Once complete, the bike path will be an integral link in the downtown Salem bicycle system. The project will connect directly to Wallace Marine Park, Riverfront Park, Minto-Brown Island Park, and the Capital Mall.

In the pile of pre-applications for the 2024-2029 cycle at the MPO, a new project would stripe bike lanes on Winter Street between Mill Creek (just south of D Street) and Court Street. (It does not include the traffic circle, however. See August discussion linked below for a little on that.)

Winter Street between Court and D Streets

Recently:

Addendum

Nice to see the Board Chair for Cherriots weigh in!

via FB

Saturday, August 14, 2021

Learn about Neighborhood Greenways and Traffic Calming on Saturday the 21st

The Bike Boulevard Advocates are hosting a mobile seminar on the greenway and the greenway toolbox for traffic calming and safety, treating it as a set of interventions portable to other neighborhoods and other routes.

via FB

This looks like something that could be very helpful, especially if you have not yet traveled on the Winter-Maple Greenway.

Here are some extended notes on each of the stops.

The staple racks on Winter St at Union St. (2019)

They'll start at Union and Winter, the site of the Saturday Market. In the off-season of 2018-2019 the City installed a pod of staple racks. Up to that point, biking to the market had been a little inconvenient, and lots of bikes were chained to trees, street signs, and other places. For a while there was even bike valet parking, which went on hiatus in 2011.

The City has seemed disinclined to finish the greenway south of D Street, finishing the connection into downtown and the Capitol Mall. Maybe this will be an opportunity to build support for that.

Monday, August 9, 2021

Three Crossings: Fairgrounds Road at Norway, Jones at Judson School, Pringle and Copper Glen

One of the important projects completed last year for the Winter-Maple Greenway was an enhanced crossing on Fairgrounds Road at Norway.

Two major reductions in the scope
(Drawings from March 2018, red comments added)

Previous drawings from 2018 had shown a lot of concrete, and since the project funding bundled it with four other crossings, and it also appeared to remove parking for a business operated by a new City Councilor, it seemed like a strong candidate for "value engineering." (See previous notes here, here, and here.)

$586,300 was not enough (April 2019)

Indeed, the as-built conditions show a shorter, more compact median refuge in Fairgrounds Road, and the second proposed median in Norway was completely deleted, saving the parking strip for the business.

Median refuge looking southwest, much shorter

Tu Casa parking strip on Norway retained

I had been prepared to find any reductions problematic, but I do not think the reductions here are in fact very problematic.

Saturday, March 6, 2021

City Council, March 8th - Speed Zones and our Autoism

Also on Council's agenda for Monday are a couple of transportation items that deserve some notice.

Two Speed Studies

Though the details are pretty wonky, the two speed studies and adjustments to posted speeds are very interesting.

And we should read them in light of the fact, as Salem Reporter noted, in West Salem on Doaks Ferry Road, a person was apparently driving lawfully at 40mph, or close enough, that after they struck and killed Selma Pierce, the "the Polk County District Attorney’s review...found there was no evidence to justify criminal charges." 

Speed kills even when there is no obvious carelessness or unlawful driving. (Previous notes here.)

At Nebraska on 17th,
70% of drivers exceed "limit."
The limit is 30mph, the average is 32,
and 85th percentile speed is 36.

I think this is the first time that we have seen a speed zone evaluated by the 50th percentile rather than 85th percentile speed. Last year ODOT changed the rules around evaluations like these, and here is what might be the first fruit of that in Salem. This is actually a remarkable moment!

Friday, May 15, 2020

City Previews Summer Construction on Safety Improvements for Walking and Biking

The City's published a release on road construction projects for this summer - in the shadow of the Pandemic it is almost hard to believe they are still moving forward, and that's something pleasant to observe.

Most of them we've been talking about for a while here, some for several years. It will be nice to see them move finally from planning studies and funding applications to real concrete, asphalt, and paint.

One of them I have not seen before. It's not the most important, but since it is novel in that sense we'll start with it. On the others, since they are not new here notes are not systematic at all.

(City of Salem)

The west crosswalk on Ferry at Liberty is terrible!
The City is going to bump out the southwest corner of Ferry and Liberty in order to shorten the crosswalk and to make drivers square up the turn rather than swoop it tight at a higher speed. In the streetview photo you can see what is a I think a Bike Cop waiting to cross there, and with vertical elements like trees and crosswalk signal post, as well as the shade, the Cop's not super visible, and getting anyone who wants to cross out farther will hopefully improve visibility.

Monday, March 2, 2020

New Governors Safety Report on Walking Raises Concern, Misses on Speed; Grant NA to try out Crossing Flags

Last week the Governors Highway Safety Association released their latest report on walking deaths and walking safety.

February 2020 report on 2019
It is an interesting and unfortunate rhyme that the cover image corresponds a little with our troubles on Market Street at Winter, right by the school.

People keep hitting stop sign on Market at Winter
(end of January and the installation last July)
Their press release singles out three points:
A number of trends offer insight into the many causes behind the rise in pedestrian fatalities:
  • Most pedestrian fatalities take place on local roads, at night and away from intersections, suggesting the need for safer road crossings and increased efforts to make pedestrians and vehicles more visible. During the past 10 years, the number of nighttime pedestrian fatalities increased by 67%, compared to a 16% increase in daytime pedestrian fatalities.
  • Many unsafe driving behaviors – such as speeding, distracted and drowsy driving – pose risks to pedestrians, and alcohol impairment by the driver and/or pedestrian was reported in nearly half of traffic crashes that resulted in pedestrian fatalities in 2018.
  • Pedestrians struck by a large SUV are twice as likely to die as those struck by a car. Although passenger cars are the largest category of vehicles in fatal pedestrian crashes, the number of pedestrian fatalities over the past decade involving SUVs increased at a faster rate – 81% – than passenger cars, which increased by 53%.
But that cover image already shows something of a problem. If that florescent yellow sign keeps getting hit, then "efforts to make pedestrians...more visible" are perhaps not the signal issue and solution.

Wednesday, February 5, 2020

Grant Neighborhood Talks Crosswalks Thursday

Grant Neighborhood Association meets on Thursday the 6th, and crossing busy streets is on the agenda.

If the sign is not safe, how are people safe?
Less than a year old, this chewed up sign
is an accurate emblem for our lack of progress.
The association will talk about the proposed crossing on Fairgrounds Road at Norway and also about difficulty crossing Market Street.

February agenda
The crossing on Fairgrounds is especially interesting. Here is what I think is the last published plan for it.

Tuesday, December 10, 2019

Bikeways in the Neighborhoods: Speed Hump Questions; New Interest near Bush Park

Will the next couple of years be when we finally decide what we are going to do about a citywide bike network? Assessing one Neighborhood Greenway and figuring out potential next steps on new ones have been topics at neighborhood associations this fall.

Highland Neighborhood Association meets on Thursday the 12th, and it sounds like the new speed humps on the Winter-Maple Greenway are not as effective as neighbors would like.

via Twitter
From the October minutes:
[S]everal neighbors had some concerns about the speed humps that had been installed on Maple St. N.E. and how it was felt that the bumps were actually not helping the area in the way it was understood it would as traffic has not slowed down. A new traffic study is being done and several others have been done in the area and once the results are compiled, [City Traffic Engineer Kevin] Hottman has promised to return to the Highland Neighborhood meeting and give a more thorough report. This will probably be sometime around March of 2020 and once the board has been notified, he will be placed on the agenda.
So this is something to watch. So far we have not much installed traffic diverters, and it may be that we need more seriously to consider them or other stronger forms of traffic calming.

The Highland Neighborhood Association meets Thursday the 12th at 7:00 p.m. in the North Neighbors Resource Center, 945 Columbia St NE.

SCAN

SCAN also meets, on Wednesday the 11th, and minutes from the last two meetings had several tidbits of note.

Taking next steps on connections immediately south of downtown has been on the minds of neighbors.

Priority Bikeways in SCAN:
Cemetery connection, Church St route, et. al.
(2017 version of TSP)

Friday, July 26, 2019

Marion Car Park Demolition, Market St Crosswalk, Falcons - Bits

With not a lot to write about, and with evenings warm, sometimes like last night a little hot, but not scorching yet so far this summer, it seemed like it might be a little interesting to follow the progress of demolition on the Marion Car Park.

But it has offered no revelations or anything particularly interesting. (Have you noticed any details in the rubble?)

The Willamette last night
The revelation instead came last night walking under the Center Street Bridge after crossing the Union St RR Bridge and finally seeing - and hearing! - the Peregrine Falcons. To have Eagles, Osprey, and now Falcons all here seems like a good sign of river health.

Tuesday the 16th

Friday, May 31, 2019

Speed Bumps on Maple, Action on Allan Bros Space: Newsbits

Yesterday the City announced they'd finished up installation of the speed bumps on the Winter-Maple Greenway.

via Twitter
Maybe over the weekend there will be a chance to check it out.

Have you used it lately? And more significantly, has anyone observed an increase in people biking on it? Does it draw in new people biking? And how does it function for kids? There was no "walk and roll to school day" hoopla earlier this month, and it had seemed like some might be keyed to the Greenway.

Is there a plan for post-construction assessment?

Governor's Cup Expanding or Moving?

Others will have more detail on whether the Governor's Cup is moving or is expanding, but details in a Hearing Notice at the Historic Landmarks Commission show that the old Allan Bros. space downtown on Liberty Street should not be vacant long and strongly suggest the Governor's Cup is going into it.

The main thing the HLC will consider is the request to eliminate the recessed porch with a new storefront system continuous with the windows and wall of the second floor. (Probably there is an anti-camping element in play here.) But it's good that the space will not be vacant long.

Some have cited the coffee shop's closing as a sign that our downtown is ill. But Allan Bros has been closing shops around the valley. In Eugene a third-wave roaster, Farmers Union Roaster, recently went in the old Allan Bros shop in 5th Street downtown, and they seem to be plenty busy. In that instance, and likely here in Salem also, the problem may have more more to do with a tired brand than problems of downtown economics or politics. Allan Bros did not seem be able to bring themselves out of a 1980s model of coffee retailing, and the market has moved on to newer styles in coffee shops. There are other ingredients also, and it's true the Starbucks on Chemeketa and Liberty closed, but it's not like Allan Bros elsewhere have been thriving. That's surely the main factor.

Here's an old photo
of the upper part of the building.
(More discussion of it here)
Because of previous rounds of remodeling, the building is designated a "non-contributing" resource ("this building does not contribute to the historic character of the district in its current condition"), and this may be another instance where our Historic District could impose disproportionate process on routine alterations. (Curiously, the Hearing Notice calls this building a "contributing resource," and this could be an error or the designation might have changed. That will be a detail to which we return.)

Dennison Building in Downtown Historic District
Probably there will be more to say when the Staff Report is published and closer to the Hearing on June 20th.

Tuesday, March 19, 2019

Church Street and SAIF, Winter-Maple Greenway, City Archiving - Bits

The City's upgraded the closure on the bridge
across the "stream of mystery"
($140k is budgeted for a fix, fortunately)
Over at CANDO they've got a note about the demolition and clearing across the street from SAIF and just north of Shelton Ditch, the sewage pump station, and Pringle Park:
CANDO is getting a new green space on Church Street at SAIF. It's not a City park, but it will be open and green. Thank you SAIF Corporation for being willing to share your space with the neighbors. Neighbors, don't get too attached, 'cause SAIF might need the space for a building again, one of these days.
This is going to be greenspace?
But with Pringle Park and the larger the path system along Shelton Ditch, Pringle Creek, and the Mill Race, is more green space something we need here? There's already that large parking garage immediately to the east. This area suffers from too much slack space and urban renewal "towers in a park" style development.

So here's a contrary take: We would be better served by one or more buildings here. What we need here are commercial and residential uses that create incidental foot-traffic for the open space, which is currently slack and underused. More green space will just intensify the slackness. See here for more on the stream of mystery and nearby open space, and notes on the "good cents" installation and the way SAIF has fenced off other open space here. Since we are fencing off areas and have difficulty finding maintenance budget to repair a bridge, these are more evidence there might be too much open space near here.

Tuesday, September 4, 2018

Winter-Maple Greenway, 25th and State: ODOT Project Scoping at MWACT

The Mid-Willamette Valley Area Commission on Transportation meets on Thursday, and they'll be seeing a preliminary list of projects for State funding in the 2021-2024 cycle.

There's not a lot of information here, and once they get farther along and SKATS takes a look at them, there might be more to say. It's also not exactly clear how far along they are in the scoping process and how many projects (or how much dollar value) will fall out as the vetting continues.

Still, there are three projects being scoped that would significantly help walking and biking in Salem.

25th & State (the spreadsheet is not a very clear scan)
The project for 25th and State "includes median island on west leg of intersection to improve visibility of pedestrians; realigning crosswalk on east leg...; upgrading ADA facilities...extending left turn pocket for westbound to southbound movement..."

The crosswalk improvements would be helpful. You might remember neighborhood advocacy on this intersection even before the State Street Study kicked off. At the same time, because the Study embraced the "hybrid" plan rather than a full 4/3 Safety Conversion, the engineering and design for this project will be different than it would have been under the 4/3 conversion, and it is even possible that the four-lane cross section will be locked in.

That's just something to monitor.
Commercial St between D & Union
The Commercial Street project from D street to Union Street includes new bike lanes, in an area that has lacked them.

That's also at the new UGM/Police facilities.

Winter-Maple Greenway package
The project on Cherry Avenue at the Parkway includes "pedestrian refuge islands," a "bike signal" at the intersection with Auto Group Way, and a "separated bike boulevard between Auto Group Way NE and Salem Parkway," all part of the Winter-Maple Greenway package.

Monday, June 11, 2018

New Stop Signs and Small Changes on Winter-Maple Greenway

Over at SBBA there's a very nice announcement from the City about new stop signs going in on the Winter-Maple Greenway:
By the end of June 2018, the City of Salem will finish the first phase of the Winter-Maple Neighborhood Greenway project to create a safe and convenient route for biking and walking between the Oregon State Capitol and Salem Parkway. This phase of the project will install stop signs at the following intersections:

D Street NE at Winter Street NE (all-way stop controlled)
Academy Street NE at Maple Avenue NE
Highland Avenue NE at Maple Avenue NE (all-way stop controlled)
Hickory Street NE at Maple Avenue NE
Spruce Street NE Maple Avenue NE
Tryon Avenue NE at Maple Avenue NE
Johnson Street NE at Maple Avenue NE

The Winter-Maple Neighborhood Greenway Project is the result of a year-long collaborative effort between the City of Salem, Oregon Department of Transportation, the Central Area Neighborhood Development Organization, and the Grant and Highland Neighborhood Associations. The new stop signs are the first step in creating a Neighborhood Greenway that improves safety, encourages a healthy lifestyle, and prioritizes bicycle and pedestrian travel. This phase of the project costs approximately $4,500 and will be paid for from the City’s general transportation maintenance budget as funded by the Oregon state gas tax.
Earlier in April they had said:
The Winter-Maple Plan was approved with the inclusion of:
- additional stop signs (to enhance safety and comfort for people on biking and walking)
- speed humps (as shown in the plan and near the OSD campus to provide self-enforcing speed control)
- a Neighborhood Greenway designation (so as to align with the national leaders in bike boulevards).
If you aren't in the neighborhood regularly and on the street, it's not always easy to envision the project. Let's look at the stop sign installation a little more closely. We'll go from south to north, mostly following the list. Some of the "additional stop signs" will become clear.

At D Street, Winter only is currently stopped
The new stop signs on D Street will also stop east-west cross traffic, which sometimes is difficult and zoomy for people going north or south on Winter Street. Maybe this will encourage through-traffic to use Market Street more.

Tuesday, April 10, 2018

Reaction to Winter-Maple Bikeway Revealing in Language

Not long after Council adjourned last night, the paper published a relatively lengthy piece on action for the Winter-Maple Family-Friendly Bikeway - or maybe now, the Winter-Maple Bicycle and Pedestrian Plan.

One of the interesting things to come out of it is the role just of language.

(update - April 11th)
From the paper's early story:
The Salem City Council on Monday approved a plan to construct a bike and pedestrian path connecting the Capitol Mall and Salem Parkway areas.

The decision followed a debate over whether to include last-minute additions proponents expect will slow traffic near the Oregon School for the Deaf.

The bike and pedestrian path, called Winter-Maple Neighborhood Greenway, doesn't appear to have a confirmed completion date, but Monday's decision paves the way for city officials to start early work on the project.
The route certainly is a "path" in the sense of a "way" or "route." But it is not primarily a path in the sense of a paved path off or out of the street right-of-way, which has seemed like it was the ordinary sense of "bike path." We have bike paths in parks, but not on our street network.

It's hard to say whether this use of "path" is a misunderstanding of the nature of the plan and the nature of low-traffic bikeways, which would be understandable since the piece was published last night, or whether it represents autoist bias and a back-handed denial of bike traffic in the street itself.

Thursday, April 5, 2018

City Council, April 9th - Winter-Maple Bikeway

Council meets on Monday and there's a surprising number of things that might be worth a comment. Chief among them is formal adoption of the Winter-Maple Family Friendly Bikeway Plan. (I'm splitting this into two posts, and I'll update a link here later for part 2.)

Coffee Shack, Drive-thru, 10 foot path
Intersection of Cherry and Auto Group Avenues
And if you wanted a nearly perfect metaphor for its execution, the plan for a coffee shack and drive-thru at one of its important intersection treatments shows a certain incoherence in land use and lack of urgency about its completion.

Wednesday, February 21, 2018

Access and Connectivity: Riverfront Park Open House 2 and Union St Bikeway at DAB

The Riverfront Park Plan has its second Open House and the Downtown Advisory Board meets tomorrow, Thursday the 22nd. Union Street figures in both of them, with the Riverfront process working with access across the railroad and Front Street, and with DAB considering funding and design for the second phase of the Union Street Bikeway.

Riverfront Park Plan Open House

The second Open House for the Riverfront Park planning process, "Community Meeting #2," is tomorrow at 6pm.

The City has published the summary from the first Open House, and it might be worth a few passing comments. First, though, from here anyway, there's a real contrast with the Downtown Streetscape project. Reading through the comments and tentative summary conclusions on the park report, everything seemed so reasonable. It seemed like the process was going to land on a reasonable compromise, one in which most people would find some things they liked, some things they didn't like so much, but something broadly very nice. Maybe not magnificent or visionary, but solid.

By contrast, the Streetscape project is already hamstrung, already hobbled and defective.

Maybe you know of some fatal compromise or defect already baked into the Riverfront Park process, and maybe the difference is merely a consequence of the fact that this is a transportation blog, not a parks blog, and so we're much more picky about sidewalks and streets than about parks. But on the whole, the Park process looks reasonable and promising.

Here are a few observations - including a few details to pick at! Most of them are about transportation and connections, naturally.

When will the path between Mirror Pond
and the Park be done?!
It was great to see that one of the most consistent questions and interests was "when will that darn path between Mirror Pond and the park be done?" That's a central matter for the City and for the Park, and it has been neglected in the sequencing and staging of the whole Boise project.
"Turn 3.8 acres into parking lot" but "don't overfill the park"
But in aggregate, people may not have a consistent sense for what they want in the park. There are reasons to worry a little about coherence:
  • At one station, "Most people visiting this station ranked attending a public event at the park as very important, while attending a private event was not important...most people were less than satisfied with existing event amenities and event space."
  • But at another station, "Perhaps the biggest area of agreement at the active recreation station focused on kayak launching and river access. Many participants were concerned with overcrowding of facilities in the park."
  • And on one comment card, a person wanted lots more parking, for the entire new Boise park parcel to be parking lot, but fretted about "overfilling" the park and asked that the band shell be removable for the view. Somehow the view of a vast parking lot was not objectionable, less so anyway than the architectural form of a band shell and stage.
The Parking and Access Station was of great interest. People applied colored dots to mark important sites or actions on the map. This confirmed the centrality of the State Street entry.

Monday, February 5, 2018

Winter-Maple Family-Friendly Bikeway at Planning Commission Tuesday

Winter St alignment, May 18th, 1899
The Plan for the Winter-Maple Bikeway goes before the Planning Commission tomorrow evening, and the City will be asking for an endorsement. (Agenda and Staff Report.)

It's an idea that's been around since at least 1899, and maybe finally it'll have some juice behind it.

Staff recommends approval and endorsement
You may recall the tepid reponse that Bike & Walk Salem got last time a substantial bike plan went before the Commission. In 2011-12, it took three meetings, in December, January, and March before the Commission sent it to Council with a recommendation for adoption.

Back in 2011 the Planning Commission was lukewarm at best
Lots of citizens showed up in support, but the testimony somehow wasn't enough for a speedy and enthusiastic endorsement. Something was lacking. (It certainly wasn't that there were elements that needed further vetting.)

Thursday, December 28, 2017

Final Winter-Maple Bikeway Plan Envisions Sluggish Implementation

Last week the City released  a final draft of the Winter-Maple Bikeway Plan. Overall, it points to ways our current formal planning paradigm is sometimes too focused on technical solutions and fails to give sufficient attention to the politics of actually realizing a plan with funding and construction.

final draft of Winter Maple Bikeway Plan
Back in May when we all got our first look at the draft concepts, you might remember a set of key challenges:
  1. Parking reduction (and potential loss of meter revenue) from angle to parallel. Will the City and State and other neighbors embrace this?
  2. How will the two businesses on Norway at Fairgrounds receive the idea of closing that small section of Norway to cars? Are they on board yet?
  3. And difficulty with the railroad in securing permission for the reconfigured crossings on Maple.
Most of the other details seemed like details too small to fuss over. The incremental difference between an 80% solution and a 90% solution is rarely all that important, and just doing something is almost always better than the status quo. In any case, there is not much change from the May draft concepts to these December final concepts.

So how the final recommendations managed these three moments will be central to an opinion of the overall plan.

Implementation does not seem very Urgent

But first, there is one overwhelming impression from the final published study.

It's not clear how serious we are. Towards the end of the plan, there is a table with a staging plan. A lot of the pieces are envisioned as "long-term" for completion five or more years out.